Snatched

Not every child who goes missing is a runaway. Every year, often as a result of a bitter custody battle, hundreds of children are abducted by a parent. Helen Gent reports

At half past four, Mary* blew out the candles on Jamie's birthday cake. Ten little flames flickered and died. And with them the hope of seeing her son was extinguished too. Three years ago, Jamie had been abducted by his father, and since then nothing. No letters, no phone calls, no word, no son.

According to recent figures, about a tenth of all missing children are abducted and of those, 95 per cent have been taken by a family member. Reunite, a charity that deals with parental child abduction, believes that around 350 children are abducted each year by a parent. And while abduction by a stranger - as in the Sarah Payne case - is still extremely rare, the figure for parental abduction is rising.

Between 1995 and 2000, there was an 87 per cent increase in abduction cases, according to Reunite.

A custody dispute is one of the major reasons for a parent abducting their child. 'A child might be abducted immediately after a court case,' says Reunite's David Huxley. 'Or if a couple are separated and have sorted out visiting rights, the child might go for a visit and never come back.'

Often, abduction is spurred by revenge rather than concern for the child's welfare. 'A parent may abduct their child not necessarily because they want to care for them, but as a way of getting back at their partner,' says David Huxley.

Home alone
It's something Catherine Meyer knows all too well. Her two children, Alexander, nine, and Constantin, seven, were abducted by her estranged husband in 1994. It was, she believes, his way of paying her back for leaving him. Today Catherine is president of Parents & Abducted Children Together (PACT), a non-profit-making organisation that campaigns on behalf of parents like herself.

  • Over the page: fighting through the courts

    It is, she says, her way of coping. 'Psychologically it helps me. It gives meaning to what has happened to me.'

    Yet what has happened is almost beyond meaning. Beyond comprehension. Catherine's children were never returned from a holiday in their father's homeland of Germany. A protracted legal battle followed. Despite Catherine being their legal custodian, the German authorities ruled that Catherine should have no access rights to Alexander and Constantin until 2003 because it would be too traumatic - after so many years of separation, she had practically become a stranger to them. Despite repeated court applications to see her children, access arrangements were reneged, rulings failed to be enforced.

    Time ticked on, years passed. More court cases, more rulings, more judgements. Until time finally ran out for Catherine. The courts ruled that it was too late to return Alexander and Constantin to England: the children had adapted to their new environment, they decided, and going back would be psychologically damaging.

    Since their abduction almost eight years ago, Catherine has seen her children for a total of 24 hours. 'People say that what has happened can't be possible,' says Catherine. 'How can a mother be denied access to her children?' How indeed.

    Local judgement
    Tracing an abducted child can be extremely difficult, says Chief Inspector Tim Bonnett, co-ordinator for the UK Missing and Exploited Children Web Site which runs an international database of missing children. Unlike runaways, who usually operate alone, an abducted child is easily led by their parent.

    'An abducted child will be in the care of somebody who has the mental capacity to hide them, to disguise them, to move much more freely,' says Chief Inspector Bonnett. He cites the case of one father who went on the run with his daughter for two years after setting up a new bank account, new credit cards and a new mobile phone. 'Basically, he was able to disappear and restart his life.'

  • Over the page: complicated cases

    The situation is further complicated when a child is taken out of the country, which often occurs when an international marriage breaks down and the parent flees to their country of origin. Although around 60 countries, including Germany, have signed up to the Hague Convention - which states that abducted children should be promptly returned to their country of habitual residence (the country they have been abducted from) - the vagaries of local judiciary systems mean this is not always put into practice.

    'If a child is taken to a Hague convention country, an abduction case may be turned around in six weeks,' says Reunite's David Huxley. But, he says, if a country hasn't signed up to the Hague agreement, or if there are complications with local law, as in Catherine Meyer's case, weeks can turn into years.

    Living in hope
    'It's like a bereavement,' says David Huxley. 'And the longer it drags on, the worse it becomes.' One woman, whose children were abducted to Libya, was finally allowed telephone contact only to discover they could no longer understand her English accent. Other parents who are lucky enough to discover their children's whereabouts will never be sure if their cards, letters and presents have ever reached them.

    And for parents whose children have been brainwashed to hate them, a reunion can be bittersweet as parent and child try to heal the rift. 'Often the child is told that their mum doesn't want them, that they will never see her again, or that she is dead,' says David Huxley.

    'You end up being vilified by the abducted child,' says Catherine. 'My sons have probably heard bad things about me, and even if they try to think of positive images of me, they might begin to believe it was true. They may believe that I have abandoned them and no longer want to see them. Because surely if I loved them, I would be there with them. They don't know how hard I've been trying.'

  • Over the page: living in hope

    And it isn't just the bereft parent who suffers. For Catherine, 'tug-of-love' is too simplistic a description for abduction cases. 'It's child abuse,' she says firmly. 'My children will be scarred for life and I, as their mother, failed to protect them. Every child should have the right to love and be loved by both its parents. Alexander and Constantin have been denied that right.'

    As Mary packs away her son's unopened presents, the one thing she has left is hope. And Catherine, too, says that's all there is. 'Without hope you die. I hope my children will grow up and want to find out where I am. It is a huge risk. I'm sure they will take it but I don't know when. He can't keep my children hostage for ever.'

    * Names have been changed

    Where to find help

  • Reunite: for practical advice and information, call 020 7375 3440 or visit their website
  • Visit PACT online
  • The UK Missing and Exploited Children Web Site