|
Make the right choice of contraception for you. Dr Sarah Brewer explains each method
Family planning is an essential part of reproductive health, letting you choose whether to have children, how many to have, and when to have them. The right contraception will help you enjoy your relationship to the full, without the worry of an unplanned pregnancy.
Choose a method:
For most women, conception is possible from their early teens to their mid-40s, and a sexually active woman who doesn't use any method of contraception has an 85% chance of becoming pregnant within one year. Surveys suggest, however, that less than 50% of sexually active women regularly use a reversible method of contraception, while those most keen to avoid pregnancy - teenagers and women over 40 - are least likely to use any form of contraception at all. As a result, around one in three pregnancies are unplanned.
Failure rates of various methods per year
The following table shows typical effectiveness rates for various methods of contraception (allowing for some human error), to help you decide which method is right for you, based on their reliability:
|
Method
|
|
Typical failure rate
|
|
No contraception
|
|
85%
|
|
Withdrawal
|
|
19% |
| Natural fertility awareness methods |
|
Up to 23% |
| Fertility awareness computer (Persona) |
|
6% or more |
| Diaphragm/cap |
|
Up to 18% |
| Spermicides alone |
|
25% |
| Male condom |
|
Up to 15% |
| Female condom |
|
Up to 15% |
| Coil (IUCD) |
|
1% to 2% |
| Progestogen coil (intra-uterine system) |
|
< 1% |
| Combined pill |
|
< 1 - 3% or more |
| Mini pill |
|
< 1 - 4% or more |
| Depot progestogen injection |
|
< 1% |
| Female sterilisation |
|
< 1% |
| Male sterilisation |
|
< 1% |
| Emergency contraceptive pill |
|
Up to 4% |
| Emergency contraceptive IUCD |
|
Up to 2% |
Combined Oral Contraceptive Pill
What it is
The combined oral contraceptive pill is one of the most reliable methods of contraception - if used properly. It contains two synthetic hormones, an oestrogen and a progestogen. It's taken every day for 21 days, and then a seven-day pill-free interval occurs, during which a progestogen withdrawal-bleed (similar to a period) usually occurs. As long as you have taken the pills as prescribed, you're still protected against pregnancy during this seven-day break. Some brands contain seven inactive pills, so you don't have to remember when to restart each pack after your pill-free break. These are known as 'every day (ED) packs'.
How it works
The combined pill prevents pregnancy by:
- stopping egg follicles ripening in the ovaries
- stopping eggs being released (ovulation)
- thickening cervical mucus so that sperm cannot swim through as easily
- thinning the lining of the womb, making it less able to support an early pregnancy
- possibly slowing transport of sperm and eggs within the Fallopian tubes
As long as you remember to take it exactly as prescribed, the combined oral contraceptive pill has a failure rate of less than 1%.
Pros
- An easily reversible form of contraception.
- Makes monthly bleeds more regular, reduces blood loss, and protects against anaemia, painful bleeds and pre-menstrual syndrome.
- Women taking the pill are less likely to develop fibroids, and it helps some women with endometriosis, by stopping ovulation.
- May reduce the risk of cancer of the womb, ovaries, colon and rectum.
Cons
- Must be taken on time, as directed.
- May fail if absorption is reduced by vomiting, diarrhoea or interaction with certain drugs, including broad-spectrum antibiotics.
- In some women, there may be a delay in conception after stopping the pill.
- May dampen libido both while you take them and for some time afterward, according to recent studies
- Unsuitable for women with blood-clotting problems.
- Unsuitable for women over the age of 35 who smoke.
- Must be stopped six weeks before a major operation.
- Has been linked, in some women, with increased blood pressure, blood clots and jaundice.
- Can cause side-effects in some women, such as weight gain, nausea, headaches, breast soreness, loss of sex drive, mood changes, intolerance to contact lenses, breakthrough bleeding and vaginal discharge.
- May increase the risk of breast cancer - while taking the pill and during the 10 years after stopping its use. However, once women have stopped taking the pill for ten or more years, no significant extra risk of breast cancer remains. This increased risk is thought to be very small.
Progestogen-only (Mini) Pill
What it is
The progestogen-only pill (POP) contains a single synthetic hormone, a progestogen, in a much lower dose than that contained in the combined pill.
How it works
The POP acts as a contraceptive by:
- thickening cervical mucus so that sperm cannot swim through as easily
- thinning the endometrial lining of the womb so that, if an egg is fertilised, it can't implant or develop
- decreasing motility of sperm and eggs within the Fallopian tubes.
The progestogen-only pill is usually started on the first day of menstrual bleeding. Contraceptive protection is then achieved within about four hours. It's taken consecutively, every day, without a tablet-free break (even during menstruation), and must be taken within three hours of its due time in order to be effective. The mini pill has a failure rate of less than 1%, when taken regularly, as prescribed. Most pregnancies are the result of forgetting one or more pills, or not taking the pills on time. User error increases the failure rate to an average of about 4%.
Pros
- An easily reversible form of contraception.
- Suitable for older women, especially smokers.
- Suitable for use during breastfeeding.
- May relieve menstrual symptoms.
- No increased risk of blood clots or high blood pressure.
- Most menstrual bleeds occurring whilst taking the mini pill are light and regular, every 28 days, although they can appear irregularly.
Cons
- Must be remembered on time every day.
- If you take a mini pill just three hours late (ie 27 hours since the last tablet), you should take extra precautions (eg use condoms) immediately, and use these for the next seven days. If you miss two or more mini pills, emergency contraception should be considered.
- The mini pill seems to be less effective in women who weigh more than 70kg (11 stones).
- Vomiting or diarrhoea will interfere with absorption, and additional contraception should be used during the illness, and for one week afterwards.
- May dampen libido both while you take them and for some time afterward, according to recent studies
- Irregular periods can occur.
- There is a small increased risk of ectopic pregnancy.
Injectable Long-acting Progestogen
What it is
The contraceptive injection is a slow-release store (depot) of a synthetic progestogen hormone (medroxyprogesterone acetate). The first injection (into your buttock or arm) is initially given during the first five days of your period (to rule out pregnancy) or within the first five weeks after childbirth. If you're breastfeeding, however, the first injection is delayed until six weeks after delivery. After your first dose, the injection is repeated every 12 weeks, as required.
How it works
The depot progestogen injection works by:
- stopping ovulation in most cycles
- thickening cervical mucus so that sperm cannot swim through as easily
- thinning the endometrial lining of the womb, so that if an egg is fertilised, it can't implant or develop
- decreasing motility of sperm and eggs within the Fallopian tubes.
Pros
- Relieves painful periods.
- No serious side-effects.
- Can be used during breastfeeding.
- Doesn't have to be remembered every day.
Cons
- Periods may be frequent, irregular, or absent.
- Some women get very heavy, erratic bleeding during the first 3 months of using this method. This doesn't usually continue after the second injection
- The injection can't be removed, so any unwanted effects may last for 12 weeks
- There can be a delay in return of fertility after stopping the injection.
- Some women gain weight.
- It reduces bone mineral density in many women who use it. This effect is greatest during the first 2-3 years of use. It isn't yet known whether this reduction in bone mineral density increases the risk of osteoporosis and fractures in later life. This effect may be more important in adolescents, as this is time when bone mineral density should be increasing to achieve peak bone mass. The bones start to recover when the injection is stopped, but it isn't yet known whether the bones ever regain full strength
Contraceptive Patch (EVRA)
What it is
A hormonal skin patch that's worn for one week at a time, and changed on the same day of the week, for three consecutive weeks. The fourth week, during which a withdrawal bleed occurs, is 'patch-free'. It can be worn on one of four body areas - the buttocks, abdomen, upper torso (excluding the breasts) or upper outer arm.
How it works
The contraceptive patch delivers a continuous flow of hormones (norelgestromin plus ethinyl estradiol) through the skin into the bloodstream. It prevents pregnancy by suppressing ovulation, like the combined pill (see entry). The hormones in the patch also thicken the cervical mucus, making it more difficult for sperm to enter the uterus. When used correctly, it's as effective in preventing pregnancy as combined oral contraceptives (failure rate less than 1%).
Pros
- Stays in place, even when exercising, swimming or bathing, and in humid conditions.
- Available in the UK on prescription from GPs and family planning clinics.
- Slim enough to be worn discreetly underneath clothing.
- Only has to be remembered once a week, rather than once a day.
Cons
- Some women forget to change the patch weekly.
- It may not be as effective in women who weigh 90kgs or more.
- A skin reaction may occur at the site of the patch, but this leads to discontinuation in less than 2% of users.
Male Condom
What it is
Male condoms are made from vulcanised latex rubber, or from polyurethane, which has the advantages of being twice as strong as latex, thinner and non-allergenic.
How it works
Condoms provide a physical barrier to prevent sperm entering the female reproductive tract. Condoms are most effective when used with a spermicidal cream or gel. Apart from protecting against any spilled sperm, this provides extra lubrication, so the condom is less likely to burst than when used dry. It's important to use only a water-based lubricant, as petroleum jelly and mineral oils such as baby oil weaken latex rubber. Condoms also help to protect against sexually transmissible infections.
When used correctly, condoms have a method failure rate of 2% to 5% per year. Typically, however, incorrect use, and the risks of bursting or coming off, increase the typical failure rate to between 11% and 15%.
Pros
- Readily available.
- Minimal side-effects.
- Effective, with careful use.
- May protect both partners against sexually transmissible disease.
- May protect women against cervical cancer and pelvic inflammatory disease.
- Can be incorporated into foreplay.
Cons
- Must be used properly. Always read the instructions closely, and avoid any genital-to-genital contact until the condom is in place.
- Interrupts spontaneity.
- Requires a high degree of motivation, if used long-term.
- Must be handled carefully.
- Reduced sensitivity for the male.
- Can cause allergy to spermicide.
- Can be expensive.
- May burst, slip or fall off.
- Discreet disposal may be a problem.
Female Condom
What it is
The female condom is a pre-lubricated, loose-fitting, disposable polyurethane sheath, which fits inside the vagina. It contains two flexible rings, one of which is attached, and remains outside the body. The smaller, inner ring sits loosely inside the sheath, and is used to help insertion. It sits up high in the vagina, and holds the sheath in position, beyond the pubic bone.
How it works
The female condom provides a physical barrier, to prevent sperm entering the female reproductive tract. It also helps to protect against sexually transmissible infections. When used carefully, the failure rate may be as little as 2%, but can be as high as 15% at 12 months.
Pros
- Provides women with a barrier method, which they can control.
- Is not dependent on erection for successful use.
- Can be inserted in advance.
- Helps to protect the vagina from friction sores.
- Less loss of sensitivity for the male, compared with latex condoms.
- The male doesn't have to withdraw immediately after ejaculation.
- Protects against sexually transmissible diseases.
Cons
- Requires pre-meditation.
- Looks large, and appearance can be off-putting.
- The penis may slip down the side of the outer ring, rather than inside.
- May not be easy to dispose of discreetly.
|